· 3 min read

When the judge’s patience runs out – who steps in when legal counsel behaves improperly?

In recent days, Finland has been debating how people behave in the courtroom.

The right to defend oneself is a central principle of a fair trial. The task of the defence is to challenge the evidence presented by the prosecutor, assess the reliability of the injured party’s account and bring out the matters relevant to the defendant. The judge’s task, in turn, is to conduct the trial and make sure that evidence is presented appropriately.

In my work as a forensic psychologist and psychotherapist, I have for years met people for whom appearing in court has been extremely taxing psychologically, precisely because of the improper treatment they experienced there. In civil litigation, perhaps the most flagrant example was the opposing party’s licensed legal counsel, who had shown my client the middle finger during a hearing. Very often I have heard of situations in which psychological symptoms diagnosed by a doctor, and their connection to the offence, have been turned against the injured party, for instance by pointing to mental health difficulties years earlier. There have also been cases in which the offence was claimed to be a product of the injured party’s imagination, even though the event had been recorded on video. It is common for the tone of questions and statements to be belittling, mocking or blaming. Advocates and judges have told me the same about such events in the courtroom.

The situation is puzzling, because the importance of meeting crime victims sensitively was recognised in Finland years ago. In particular, the Tukinainen Rape Crisis Centre did significant development work in its Senja project as early as 2009–2013, training judges, prosecutors and legal counsel to meet crime victims. The Victim Policy Action Programme for 2026–2030, published in July 2026, continues this training and development work. I consider it important that the training of legal professionals is also delivered by clinical experts with practical experience of meeting crime victims and of the effects of traumatisation.

So the training work has been done, and it has been important. The next question is how this competence is ensured in actual trials, and what really happens when an injured party is treated improperly.

As far as I understand, a judge has at least the following means available:

1

Interrupting or disallowing a question.

If a question is irrelevant to the case, unnecessarily offensive or otherwise improper, the judge can intervene without delay.

2

Requiring a question to be rephrased.

A question that is necessary for establishing the facts can be required to be put without personal or humiliating language.

This does not mean that the judge should protect the injured party from all difficult questions. The judge’s task is to make sure that questions serve to establish the facts and that the trial remains proper.

I do not know whether the most flagrant and serious cases have ever led to consequences in practice. Finnish law provides that a court must refuse questions that are irrelevant, misleading or otherwise improper. The court can also intervene in counsel’s conduct more broadly. If a legal representative or counsel proves to be dishonest, lacking in understanding or unskilled, or is otherwise found unfit for the role, the court may prohibit them from appearing in the case in question. The court may also, where there is reason to do so, prohibit them from acting as a legal representative or counsel in that court for up to three years. The court must notify the decision to the Supervisory Board, which oversees advocates, public legal aid attorneys and licensed legal counsel. The court may also notify the Supervisory Board of other conduct in breach of counsel’s duties. Such a notification does not require a prohibition on appearing to have been imposed.

The Supervisory Board, in turn, can impose a disciplinary sanction for a breach of professional conduct. The options are a remark, a warning, a sanction fee and, in the most serious cases, revocation of the licence.

The problem will not be solved by training alone. What is needed is clear procedures, a lower threshold for intervening in improper conduct and credible consequences when professional duties are breached. The court’s power to bring improper conduct before the Supervisory Board must not remain merely a possibility written into the law.

The purpose of a trial is to establish what happened. That goal should also guide how people are treated in a trial.