· 4 min read

The Elizabeth Holmes case: How can a person keep seeing themselves as moral after causing enormous harm to others?

The United States has been abuzz about You Can See Everything, a documentary on Elizabeth Holmes and her company Theranos released in October 2026.

Found guilty in 2022 on four counts of defrauding investors, Holmes is currently serving a prison sentence of 11 years and three months, with a restitution order of 452 million dollars that she owes jointly with her former business partner. In an interview she gave People magazine from prison, Holmes says she never thought she would be found guilty or sentenced.

I watched the documentary The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley (2019), which includes interviews with Holmes, and analysed the behaviour it shows against what I know about leadership, psychopathy, narcissism, manipulation, lying, white-collar offenders and deceit.

In the documentary, I paid particular attention to the following:

  • Appeals to pity and sympathy in the company’s origin story and in the face of setbacks. Research shows this to be the most effective technique of social influence.
  • An outstanding ability to sell, draw others in and argue persuasively, even though the substance of the arguments is clumsy and in itself reveals a serious level of ignorance.
  • The leader’s presence at a job interview makes the applicant feel important, which breeds loyalty.
  • Misleading marketing, lying and exaggeration about her own overly optimistic, grandiose achievements or prospects.
  • Recruiting allies and using them as needed – for example, using high-status people in the company’s marketing who had no real connection to the company.
  • Adding her own name to employees’ independent, significant work, such as patents.
  • Pressuring and threatening employees, and dismissing those who questioned the company’s conduct, with threats attached. The documentary also describes lawyers representing the company being used to pressure and harass former employees.
  • Intense suspicion of anything that might threaten the company.
  • Exaggeratedly theatrical, overstated argumentation.
  • Complete disregard for the field’s ethics or rules, and an accompanying sense of entitlement.
  • Playing for time by burying matters in irrelevant detail when the company’s conduct is questioned. Giving misleading or false information to regulators.
  • Irresponsibility, denial of facts, whitewashing and brazenness. External attribution – shifting the blame for difficulties onto things outside oneself.
  • Intense eye contact in situations where the person is being challenged.

Without taking a position on Holmes’s personality, the corporate culture and leadership style depicted in the documentary resemble in many respects how the conduct of leaders with strong narcissistic or psychopathic traits has been described. The Holmes case therefore raises the question of which psychological mechanisms can make such conduct possible – and above all, allow it to continue for years.

An interesting systematic review, Cognitive Biases and Moral-Regulatory Mechanisms in White-Collar Crime, was published in October 2026. It examined 107 studies on the psychological mechanisms of white-collar crime.

The review’s central finding was that, alongside personality, white-collar crime is explained by what is known as moral neutralisation. A person can tell themselves that what they are doing is not really wrong, because in their view it serves a greater purpose, others do the same, or no one is actually harmed. The review also covered overconfidence and the illusion of control. A person may overestimate their own abilities, underestimate the risk of getting caught and believe they can stay in control of the situation, even when the facts point the other way.

The documentary describes Holmes, among other things, as a zealot blind to reality. It left me wondering whether she genuinely believed in her cause because it served her possibly grandiose sense of self-worth and self-importance. A person can knowingly lie about individual facts while holding on to a larger narrative in which they are well-meaning, misunderstood or chosen for an exceptional mission.

When one’s self-image is tightly bound to the company’s success, admitting failure can become ever harder. A narcissistic or psychopathic person is often unable to accept their own mistakes, because doing so does not fit their self-image. There is also a snowball effect. Once the first false claim or misleading act has been made, keeping it from coming to light may require new lies and new misconduct. Employees who ask questions or insist on honesty are isolated, bullied and driven out of the company. If allies from inside the company join in, they can feed the leader’s grandiose sense of self-worth and illusion of invulnerability. At least one Theranos scientist took his own life as a result.

One of the most intriguing questions in the Theranos story is how so many people, some of them extremely influential, believed in Holmes. A leader’s persuasiveness, strong vision and ability to make others feel important can create a powerful desire to be part of the story. When this is combined with silencing critical voices through threats and intimidation, it can become difficult to bring misconduct to light or to question it. The situation can become particularly problematic when the leadership’s goals are considered so important that practices which would otherwise be clearly unethical are accepted in order to reach them.

The Theranos case and many similar cases show that the ship of such a company may sink at some point, leaving those still on board asking themselves: “How was I taken in for so long?” In the documentary, a former employee put it aptly:

If you work for a company like this, ask yourself: would you buy its service yourself?